Is Sophie Really a Naughty Girl, or Just Finding Herself? A New Look at Les Malheurs de Sophie

Many of us grew up with stories like Good Night Stories for Rebel Girls, celebrating girls who challenge expectations. But what about classic tales like Les Malheurs de Sophie (Sophie’s Misfortunes)? This French children’s book tells the story of a mischievous young girl, but is Sophie just naughty, or is there more to the story?

From Rebel to Reform:

Mangerson (2021) states that Good Night Stories for Rebel Girls empowers girls to break the mold, but Les Malheurs de Sophie has the opposite goal: 

1. Sophie is constantly in trouble, and the story presents her behavior as something she needs to overcome to become a “good girl.”

Why is Sophie Still Popular?

Despite its seemingly outdated message, Les Malheurs de Sophie remains popular
. This suggests that some aspects of Sophie’s transformation might still resonate with readers today. But what if we looked at the story through a different lens?

Beyond Naughty or Nice:

This is where things get interesting. Literary scholars are proposing a new way to understand Sophie’s character.  Maybe her “misfortunes” aren’t just about bad behavior but about her struggle to find her place in a world with strict gender expectations.

Is Sophie Gender-Fluid?

The idea is that Sophie might not be a “naughty girl” but a child who hasn’t yet settled into a binary gender identity (think boy or girl). Her love of climbing trees and playing with toy soldiers might not be signs of naughtiness but of exploring different ways of being.

The Power of Stories:

Children’s literature plays a significant role in shaping how kids see themselves and the world. Stories like Les Malheurs de Sophie can reinforce traditional ideas about gender. But this analysis encourages us to think critically – are these stories helping or limiting young readers?

Sophie’s Adventures:

The complete analysis dives deeper into specific moments from Les Malheurs de Sophie. It explores how Sophie’s play choices, her desire for adventure, and even her friendships are judged through the lens of femininity during that time. (Mangerson, 2021)

So, what do you think?  Is Sophie a naughty girl, or is there more to the story?  Let us know in the comments below!

References

1.  Mangerson, Polly. (2021). Naughty Girl, or Not a Girl? Behavior and Becoming in Les Malheurs de Sophie. Open Cultural Studies. 5. 273-283. 10.1515/culture-2020-0134.